After
Wayne Holland, co-chair, Alliance for Fair Trade in Beef, told the
Standing Committee on Agriculture the beef industry was in turmoil, MP
Howard Hilstrom said "I couldn’t agree with you more."
Hilstrom said that when Minister Bob
Speller had been before the committee, he was asked who was in charge of
getting the borders open. "He gave half a statement that he was in
charge." But the minister of health was also in charge of part, as
was the Prime Minister and the trade minister.
Being in charge is more than about
borders. After more than nine months the federal government has still not
taken any leadership in bringing order to the industry. John Newman,
executive member of the Ontario Cattlemen’s Association, says the
government has not stepped in to link the needs of the processors,
packers, supermarkets and producers.
The one bright light in the whole
mad cow fiasco is the Federal Standing Committee on Agriculture. It is
composed of knowledgeable members of parliament bent on getting the
industry back on track.
But it hasn’t the power it needs.
The three major packing plants in the west, two of them, Cargill and
Tyson, said to control 60 to 70 per cent of the feedlot market along with
the slaughter capacity, didn’t show up at the hearing. All three packers
had been sent a letter.
Weeks before, MP Larry McCormick at
a BSE meeting in Perth said people who were coming to the hearings were
not under oath and weren’t being subpoenaed. "These are CEOs,"
he said. "They’ll tell the truth." Some on the standing
committee are changing their minds. One MP asked that the books of the
packers and their CEOs be subpoenaed.
Despite the reluctance of packers to
reveal their books, some evidence is occurring that price gouging is
taking place. The amount of money farmers received from their cattle was
down more than $2 billion dollars in 2003, according to Statistics Canada.
At the same time, the George Morris Centre in Guelph has reported that
packer profits between October 6 and February 15 have been approximately
$227 million. What’s more, the Canadian Boxed Beef Report for the week
ending February 16 said profits were $350 per head compared to $120 per
head a year earlier.
With all of this going on the
Competition Bureau of Canada says it can’t do anything because nobody is
breaking the law. That policy has to be changed if the government is to do
something about predatory pricing. But right now farmers find themselves
in a position where they are at the mercy of government inaction and
bureaucratic indifference.
Unfortunately, a political
leadership vacuum exists in the Ontario Government. Utter "Premier
McGuinty" at a meeting and a groan of derision rises from the farm
audience. He’s hired more meat inspectors and more water inspectors. His
land assessors are overtaxing. Sawmills are closing, sugar bushes are
trying to stay solvent. He’s destroying the rural economy.
When Farmers Forum phoned
McGuinty’s office about the cow cull program, the PR officer didn’t
know much other than what was on the press release. She would give us a
quote from the premier himself, she said. But for more information, we
would have to go elsewhere.
The point is that the McGuinty
government is not interested in giving information or serving people. It’s
interested, like its counterpart in Ottawa, in developing programs that
will get it re-elected. McGuinty has no agricultural program. The new
minister, Mr. what’s his name, is more laid back than his federal
counterpart Bob Speller.
At the same time a rural revolt is
brewing. Smaller meetings have occurred in Niagara Falls, Peterborough and
Quinte. But in Renfrew and Lanark the meetings have overfilled the
community halls.
Small business owners have had
enough of ridiculous environmental programs, designed more as make work
projects than anything that will help the environment. Rural people have
had enough of inspectors with the powers of the German Gestapo. Rural
people are fed up with bending to the will of urban people.
They are fed up with government organizations that
don’t work and can’t manage the money they’re given. They’re fed
up with government appointments based on political cronyism, and the
inevitable results: High taxation and incompetent performance. It’s time
to speak with one voice, to take back lost markets and land. But Quebec
leaders speaking at a Renfrew meeting didn’t believe Ontario farmers had
suffered enough. They say only then will they demand their leadership
speak with one voice.