The Minister of Environment appears
bent on protecting the environment no matter how outrageous the cost to
farmers.
Oblivious to this charge by local
farmers, Leona Dombrowsky has argued that you can see she values farmers
by looking at the committees that will bring in source water protection.
A scan of the 21-member
implementation committee and the 16-member expert committee shows a
preponderance of environmental groupies but only two farmers, Allen
Gardiner, member of the executive committee for OFA, and John Maaskant, a
director with Chicken Farmers of Ontario. David Armitage, policy
researcher with OFA, rounds out the agricultural component.
The group has scads of conservation
managers, professor environmentalists, one member of Ducks Unlimited, one
environmental lawyer, and several hydrologists.
The second committee or expert
committee is heavy with environmentalists, including John Fitzgibbon of
the University of Guelph. A colleague of his and member of the committee
Michael Goss had focussed on the movement of bacteria in the soil in
research.
Gordon Surgeoner, also from U of G,
is on the implementation committee. He’s a PR type, who is touted at U
of G as being CEO of Ontario Agri-Foods Technologies, an impressive title
until you see the company publishes a web page consisting of articles from
around the world on agriculture. The endeavour is supported by money from
the ministry of agriculture and the Agricultural Adaptation Council.
The experts include several
hydrologists, along with head well protection researchers from Ottawa and
Waterloo Universities.
In total, the minister appointed two
farmers among the 37 and one policy advisor from OFA. The University of
Guelph has landed three appointments, all with pro environmental leanings,
and only one with substantive research.
Winchester dairy farmer Dennis St.
Pierre, an expert on how environmental committees work, says the push for
change is coming from the universities and they’ll control the agenda.
"Farmers don’t have a
chance," he said. As in the feminist movement, the professors have
been influencing students for decades. "They always stress
health," he said. That’s their trump card.